What are the failures of ball screws?

Aug 05, 2025

Leave a message

Claire
Claire
Linear Motion Application Engineer, DLY Automation Specializing in ball screw and linear guideway selection, system integration, and OEM technical support for CNC and automation applications.

Ball screws are widely used in machine tools, CNC equipment, automation systems, and precision machinery because they can convert rotary motion into accurate linear motion with high efficiency and repeatability.

However, in real machine operation, ball screw failures may still occur because of preload problems, support bearing errors, misalignment, foreign matter, over travel, poor lubrication, handling damage, or structural stress.

This article focuses on three common types of ball screw failures: excessive clearance, unsmooth operation, and fracture. Each failure type is explained by symptom, possible cause, inspection direction, and prevention method.

Why Ball Screw Failures Matter

A ball screw failure can affect positioning accuracy, repeatability, motion smoothness, equipment safety, and production stability. In CNC machines or precision automation systems, even a small amount of clearance, rough movement, or bearing misalignment may lead to machining error, abnormal noise, unstable load, or premature component wear.

When troubleshooting a ball screw, it is important not to judge the screw alone. The nut, support bearings, nut seat, bearing seat, coupling, motor connection, mounting surface, lubrication, and working environment should also be checked as part of the complete transmission system.

Common Ball Screw Failure Symptoms

Different ball screw failures often show different symptoms. The table below gives a quick way to connect visible machine problems with possible failure types.

Symptom Possible Failure Type First Check
Large backlash or lost motion Excessive clearance Preload, support bearing, coupling, nut seat, and axial play
Rough movement or jamming Unsmooth operation Ball track, lubrication, contamination, return pipe, and alignment
Noise or vibration Installation error or wear problem Bearing support, coupling alignment, lubrication, and raceway condition
Sudden blockage Over travel, foreign matter, or return pipe damage Limit switch, travel setting, ball circulation path, and return pipe
Broken steel balls, return pipe, or screw end Fracture Impact, over travel, lubrication, stress concentration, and support alignment

Failure Type 1: Excessive Clearance

Excessive clearance may appear as backlash, delayed response, poor repeatability, table movement error, or different clearance values at different travel positions. It can come from insufficient preload, weak support structure, incorrect bearing selection, poor installation, or looseness in the drive connection.

No Preload or Insufficient Preload

A ball screw without proper preload may have noticeable axial play. In vertical installation, the nut may rotate or slide under its own weight if the structure is not controlled properly. This type of clearance can reduce positioning accuracy and repeatability.

Preload should be selected according to the machine requirement. Too little preload may cause clearance, while too much preload may increase friction, heat, motor load, and wear.

Too Much Torsional Displacement

Excessive torsional displacement can occur when the screw shaft is not rigid enough for the application. It may be related to heat treatment, material hardness, screw diameter, total length, and support method.

The original technical notes mention that the standard hardness reference for steel balls, ball nuts, and screw spindles may be around HRC 62–66, HRC 58–62, and HRC 58–62 respectively. If hardness distribution is poor or the hardened layer is too thin, the screw may become less resistant to wear and deformation.

The length-to-diameter ratio also affects rigidity. A very long and thin screw is more likely to twist or bend under load. For long travel applications, screw diameter and end support method should be checked carefully.

Inappropriate Bearing Selection

Ball screw supports must control axial movement properly. Regular deep groove ball bearings are usually not suitable for carrying significant axial load in a ball screw support position. If the bearing type cannot provide enough axial rigidity, backlash may appear under load.

For ball screw installation, angular contact bearings or matched ball screw support units are commonly used at the fixed end. The support type should match the screw diameter, load, speed, and installation structure.

Inappropriate Bearing Installation

Even when the bearing type is correct, poor installation can still create clearance. If the screw shoulder is too long or too short, or if the locking nut and bearing support surfaces are not perpendicular, the bearing may tilt or fail to clamp the screw correctly.

The bearing shoulder, locking nut thread, and support surface should be processed and assembled accurately. Poor perpendicularity or parallelism in this area may lead to axial play, uneven loading, and premature support bearing wear.

Weak Nut Housing or Bearing Housing

If the ball nut housing or bearing housing is not rigid enough, it may deflect under the weight of the moving part or under machining load. This deflection can make the system appear to have clearance even if the ball screw itself is not the only problem.

Nut seat rigidity, bearing seat rigidity, mounting bolt strength, and machine frame stiffness should be checked together when excessive clearance appears.

Loose Housing or Poor Mounting

A ball nut housing or bearing housing may become loose because of vibration, insufficient fixing, missing positioning pins, incorrect screw length, shallow threaded holes, or lack of anti-loosening measures.

In practical maintenance, check whether the mounting bolts are tight, whether positioning pins are reliable, and whether the housing has shifted under repeated load.

Poor Parallelism or Flatness of the Mounting Surface

If the mating surfaces of the machine body, nut seat, bearing seat, or guide system are out of tolerance, clearance may change at different positions along the travel. This is common when the mounting surface is not flat, the guide rail alignment is poor, or adjustment shims are not applied correctly.

When clearance changes from one travel position to another, the machine body, guide rails, nut seat, and bearing seat should be inspected together.

Poor Assembly Between Motor and Ball Screw

The drive connection may also cause lost motion. If the coupling is loose, not rigid enough, or not securely mounted, relative rotation may occur between the motor shaft and ball screw shaft.

If gears or belts are used in the drive mechanism, gear mesh, belt tension, key fit, shaft sleeve fit, and timing belt selection should be checked. A loose key or slipping belt may look like ball screw clearance but actually comes from the drive system.

Cause Effect What to Check
Insufficient preload Backlash and poor repeatability Nut preload and axial play
Long and thin screw shaft Lower spindle rigidity and possible torsional displacement Screw diameter, total length, and support method
Wrong bearing type Axial play under load Angular contact bearing or support unit type
Poor bearing installation Bearing tilt, poor clamping, or unstable axial support Shoulder length, locking nut, perpendicularity, and parallelism
Weak housing Deflection under load Nut seat and bearing seat rigidity
Poor drive connection Relative rotation or drive backlash Coupling, key, belt, gear mesh, and motor alignment

Failure Type 2: Unsmooth Operation

Unsmooth operation may appear as rough movement, jamming, uneven resistance, abnormal motor load, vibration, or noise. This type of failure is often related to ball circulation, contamination, processing accuracy, over travel, return pipe damage, or alignment problems.

Problems with Screw or Nut Processing

If the ball groove surface of the screw or nut is rough, if the roundness of the steel balls or raceway is out of tolerance, or if lead error and pitch diameter are not controlled properly, the ball screw may not run smoothly.

Improper return pipe assembly or uneven steel ball size and hardness may also affect ball circulation, causing vibration, rough motion, or local jamming.

Foreign Matter Entering the Ball Track

Foreign matter is a common reason for unsmooth ball screw movement. Packaging materials, dust, chips, rust-prevention residues, or machining debris may enter the ball track and disturb normal ball circulation.

When foreign matter enters the raceway, the balls may slide instead of rolling normally, or even become blocked. This can reduce accuracy, increase noise, and shorten service life. Scrapers, covers, proper cleaning, and careful unpacking help reduce this risk.

Over Travel

Over travel can damage the return path, dent the circulation structure, or cause peeling on the ball groove surface. Once the ball circulation path is damaged, the screw may become rough, blocked, or unable to rotate properly.

Over travel may come from incorrect machine settings, limit switch failure, collision, or control error. If over travel occurs, the ball screw should be inspected before it is reinstalled and used again.

Damaged Return Pipe

A return pipe may be dented or damaged during installation, handling, or machine collision. Since the return pipe guides the balls back into circulation, even a small deformation may affect ball movement.

If the ball screw suddenly becomes stuck or noisy after installation, the return pipe and ball circulation path should be checked carefully.

Misalignment

If the nut seat and bearing seat are not concentric, radial load may be generated. Excessive eccentricity can cause the screw to bend. Even smaller eccentricity may create abnormal wear and reduce accuracy over time.

The higher the nut preload, the more sensitive the ball screw becomes to alignment error. For preloaded ball screws, the nut seat, bearing seat, coupling, motor shaft, and guideway alignment should be checked more carefully.

Improper Fit Between the Nut and Nut Seat

If the ball nut is installed at an angle or mounted eccentrically in the nut seat, abnormal load may be applied to the nut. This can cause unstable running resistance and may appear as motor load fluctuation during operation.

The nut seat should be machined and assembled so that the nut is supported evenly without forced distortion.

Damage During Handling

Ball screws can be damaged by impact, bending, dropping, or hitting the return pipe during transport and installation. Since ball screws are precision transmission components, improper handling may create problems before the machine even starts running.

During handling, the screw should be supported properly, kept clean, and protected from impact. The nut should not be removed carelessly unless proper ball retention measures are used.

Failure Type 3: Fracture

Fracture is a more serious ball screw failure. It may involve steel ball fracture, return pipe depression or fracture, or breakage at the spindle end. These failures are often related to lubrication failure, impact, over travel, stress concentration, or repeated abnormal load.

Steel Ball Fracture

Steel ball fracture may occur when operating temperature, lubrication condition, load, or local stress becomes abnormal. The original failure notes point out that the temperature rise of a lubricated and unlubricated ball screw can be significantly different.

If lubrication is insufficient, friction and heat increase. This may damage the balls, nut raceway, or screw groove. Lubrication planning should be considered in both machine design and routine maintenance.

Return Pipe Depression or Fracture

Over travel of the nut or direct impact on the return pipe can cause dents or fractures. Once the return pipe is damaged, the ball circulation path may be obstructed, causing balls to slide instead of roll.

This can lead to rough movement, blockage, internal damage, and eventually return pipe fracture. Reliable travel limits and careful installation are important for preventing this failure.

Ball Screw Spindle End Breakage

Breakage at the ball screw spindle end may be caused by improper design, stress concentration, poor shoulder structure, screw neck bending, radial force, or repeated alternating stress.

The screw shoulder should avoid sharp angles where local stress may concentrate. The perpendicularity between the bearing support surface and the thread axis of the locking nut should also be controlled carefully.

If installation eccentricity creates abnormal radial force, repeated shear stress may cause premature failure at the spindle end. This is why bearing seat alignment and support structure design are important for long-term operation.

Ball Screw Failure Troubleshooting Table

The table below summarizes the three main failure types and practical troubleshooting direction.

Failure Type Typical Symptoms Main Inspection Direction
Excessive clearance Backlash, poor repeatability, delayed response, clearance changes during travel Preload, bearing type, bearing installation, housing rigidity, mounting surface, coupling
Unsmooth operation Rough movement, jamming, noise, vibration, unstable motor load Raceway, steel balls, return pipe, contamination, over travel, alignment, nut seat fit
Fracture Broken balls, return pipe damage, spindle end breakage, sudden failure Lubrication, impact, over travel, stress concentration, radial force, support alignment

How to Prevent Ball Screw Failures

Most ball screw failures are related to installation, support, lubrication, protection, or operating conditions. Preventive measures should be planned before installation and maintained during machine operation.

Prevention Point Practical Action
Preload control Use suitable preload according to accuracy, rigidity, speed, and heat requirement.
Support bearing selection Select proper ball screw support units and check fixed-end bearing installation.
Alignment Keep motor, coupling, screw shaft, nut seat, and bearing seat aligned.
Protection Prevent chips, dust, packaging debris, and foreign matter from entering the ball track.
Lubrication Maintain proper lubrication interval and check grease condition regularly.
Travel limit Set reliable limit switches and avoid over travel or machine collision.
Handling Avoid impact, bending, dropping, or hitting the return pipe during transport and installation.

DLY Ball Screw Failure Analysis Reference

DLY supplies ball screws, ball nuts, support units, and customized end machining for CNC machines, automation equipment, packaging machinery, and industrial motion systems.

For ball screw failure analysis, preload, support bearing selection, end machining, nut seat rigidity, bearing seat alignment, coupling connection, lubrication, protection, and working environment should be checked together. A ball screw failure is often a system issue rather than only a screw shaft issue.

Conclusion

Common ball screw failures can generally be grouped into excessive clearance, unsmooth operation, and fracture. Excessive clearance is often related to preload, bearing support, housing rigidity, mounting accuracy, or drive connection. Unsmooth operation is commonly linked to contamination, processing problems, over travel, return pipe damage, misalignment, or handling damage. Fracture may involve steel balls, return pipes, or spindle ends under abnormal load or poor lubrication.

Troubleshooting should start from the visible symptom, then check the ball screw, nut, support bearings, coupling, nut seat, bearing seat, mounting surface, lubrication, and operating condition step by step.

Proper preload, correct support bearing selection, accurate installation, reliable protection, regular lubrication, and careful handling can help reduce many common ball screw failure risks.

Need Help Checking a Ball Screw Failure?

If you are checking excessive clearance, rough movement, return pipe damage, support bearing problems, end machining, or installation alignment, you can send the model, drawing, failure symptom, load, travel length, or machine application for reference.

 

Email: export@dlybearing.com

Send Inquiry