To avoid reaching the critical speed of a ball screw, first calculate the rotational speed required by the target linear speed. Then compare it with the screw shaft's critical speed, the ball nut's DN-based permissible speed and the limits of the support bearings, coupling and motor.
The allowable operating speed is determined by the lowest of these limits. For a long rotating screw, shaft critical speed is often the controlling factor because it decreases rapidly as the unsupported screw length increases.
What Is Ball Screw Critical Speed?
Critical speed is the rotational speed at which the rotating screw shaft approaches one of its natural bending frequencies. At or near this speed, the shaft can resonate and develop severe lateral vibration, commonly described as screw whip.
Possible consequences include:
- Rapidly increasing vibration and noise;
- Unstable positioning and surface-finish errors;
- Additional load on the ball nut and support bearings;
- Coupling, seal or bearing damage;
- Permanent bending or mechanical failure in severe cases.
Critical speed is not one fixed rpm for all ball screws. It changes with the screw's root diameter, unsupported length, end-support condition, straightness, installation alignment and rotating mass.
Unsupported screw length and end-support rigidity strongly affect the critical speed of a rotating ball screw.
Critical Speed Is Not the Only Speed Limit
A screw may remain below its shaft critical speed but still exceed the allowable speed of the ball circulation system. The complete selection must therefore compare several limits.
| Speed limit | What it protects | Main inputs |
|---|---|---|
| Screw shaft critical speed | Prevents shaft resonance and lateral whip | Root diameter, unsupported length and end-support arrangement |
| DN-based permissible speed | Protects the ball circulation system and nut from excessive ball speed | Ball-circle diameter, nut structure and rotational speed |
| Support-bearing speed | Prevents excessive bearing temperature and premature bearing damage | Bearing type, preload, lubrication and support-unit structure |
| Motor and coupling limit | Maintains stable drive transmission and control | Motor speed, coupling rating, inertia and acceleration |
Step 1: Convert Linear Speed into Screw Rotational Speed
Required screw speed is calculated from the target linear speed and ball screw lead:
n = v × 1000 / p
n = screw speed in rpm
v = linear speed in m/min
p = ball screw lead in mm/revolution
For example, an axis requiring a linear speed of 20 m/min would need:
| Ball screw lead | Target linear speed | Required screw speed |
|---|---|---|
| 5 mm | 20 m/min | 4,000 rpm |
| 10 mm | 20 m/min | 2,000 rpm |
| 20 mm | 20 m/min | 1,000 rpm |
This example shows why a larger lead can help a high-speed axis remain below its rotational limit. It does not prove that the 20 mm lead is automatically suitable: torque, load capacity, positioning resolution, nut circulation speed and acceleration must still be checked.
Step 2: Confirm the Unsupported Screw Length
Critical speed is highly sensitive to the unsupported length between the effective bearing support points. The relationship is approximately:
Critical speed ∝ root diameter ÷ unsupported length2
Because the length term is squared, increasing the unsupported length can reduce critical speed much more severely than expected. Use the distance between the effective bearing support points, not merely the commanded machine stroke or the overall cut length of the screw.
Also include:
- The screw sections between the nut travel and support bearings;
- The length of machined shaft ends that affect bearing position;
- Any overhanging section beyond the bearing;
- The real location and rigidity of the fixed and floated supports.
Step 3: Use the Correct Root Diameter
Critical-speed calculations normally use the screw root or minor diameter, not the nominal outside diameter printed in the model number. For example, a nominal 25 mm ball screw has a smaller root diameter after the ball groove is formed.
Using the nominal diameter instead of the actual calculation diameter will overestimate shaft stiffness and critical speed. Obtain the root diameter from the manufacturer's technical data or confirmed screw drawing.
Increasing the screw diameter generally increases bending stiffness and critical speed, but it also increases rotating inertia, motor demand, support-unit size and cost. Diameter selection must therefore be checked together with acceleration and motor capacity.
Step 4: Check the End-Support Arrangement
Critical speed depends on how the screw shaft is constrained at both ends. A more rigid support arrangement normally provides a higher critical speed than a screw with one poorly supported or free end.
| Support condition | Relative critical-speed capability | Practical note |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed–free | Lowest | Generally unsuitable for a long, high-speed rotating screw |
| Supported–supported | Higher than fixed–free | Actual performance depends on bearing clearance and housing rigidity |
| Fixed–supported | Common practical arrangement | Fixed side controls axial position; floated side supports the opposite end |
| Fixed–fixed | Highest among common end conditions | Requires careful alignment and thermal-expansion design |
Support labels alone are not enough. Loose bearing fits, incorrect locknut tightening, flexible housings or poor mounting surfaces can make an installation behave less rigidly than the theoretical support arrangement.
DLY supplies BK/BF, FK/FF and EK/EF ball screw support units that can be matched according to the screw diameter, shaft-end machining and installation layout.
Critical-speed calculations must use the effective distance between the actual bearing support points.
Step 5: Apply the Correct Safety Margin
Do not deliberately operate at the theoretical resonance speed. The allowable operating value should include the safety factor specified by the ball screw manufacturer or calculation method.
Some catalog calculation methods already multiply the theoretical critical speed by a safety factor such as 0.8. Check the definition before applying an additional factor, otherwise the safety margin may accidentally be counted twice.
The final speed setting should also consider:
- Manufacturing and installation tolerances;
- Screw straightness and balance;
- Coupling and bearing condition;
- Acceleration, deceleration and transient overspeed;
- Changes in the machine structure during long-term operation.
Practical Ways to Increase the Safe Linear Speed
| Design change | Why it helps | Trade-off to check |
|---|---|---|
| Use a larger screw diameter | Increases shaft bending stiffness and critical speed | Higher inertia, motor demand, size and cost |
| Reduce unsupported length | Strongly increases critical speed because length is a squared term | Stroke, bearing position and nut travel clearance |
| Use a larger lead | Produces the same linear speed at lower screw rpm | Drive torque, resolution, nut type and DN limit |
| Improve support rigidity | Raises the effective end-fixity coefficient | Bearing preload, alignment and thermal expansion |
| Limit motor speed in the controller | Prevents steady-state and commanded overspeed | Actual process cycle time |
| Use a rotating-nut arrangement | Keeps a long screw shaft stationary and avoids rotating-shaft whip | More complex nut drive, bearing and lubrication structure |
For conventional rotating-screw applications, DLY's high-speed ball screw options can be reviewed according to the required diameter, lead, speed, stroke and nut structure. The product's permissible rotational speed must still be checked for the actual installation.
For a very long axis where rotating-shaft critical speed becomes the main limitation, a rotating-nut ball screw set may be considered because the long screw shaft remains stationary while the nut rotates.
Installation Problems That Can Resemble Critical-Speed Vibration
Not every vibration at high speed means that the calculated critical speed has been reached. Similar symptoms can result from:
- Misalignment between the motor, coupling, screw and support units;
- A bent screw shaft or excessive straightness error;
- Loose bearing housings or mounting bolts;
- Incorrect bearing preload or locknut tightening;
- An unbalanced coupling or rotating component;
- Damaged ball circulation components;
- A servo-tuning or structural resonance problem elsewhere in the machine.
If vibration occurs at one repeatable rpm, reduce the speed and check the complete assembly before continuing operation. Do not repeatedly pass through a severe resonance range merely to confirm the noise.
Information Needed for a Speed Check
To evaluate a ball screw for critical speed and high-speed operation, prepare:
- Ball screw model and nominal diameter;
- Actual root diameter or complete screw drawing;
- Lead and number of thread starts;
- Total screw length and unsupported length;
- Effective stroke and required linear speed;
- Fixed- and floated-side support arrangement;
- Motor maximum speed and acceleration profile;
- Operating load and installation direction;
- Ball nut type and manufacturer DN limit.
In practical selection, total screw length alone is not enough. DLY normally needs the effective stroke, support positions, end-machining drawing, lead and target speed to check whether the proposed ball screw configuration is appropriate.
Conclusion
Avoiding ball screw critical speed starts with calculating the actual rpm required for the target linear speed. That rpm must then remain below the allowable value determined by shaft critical speed, DN limit, support bearings, coupling and motor.
For long or high-speed axes, the most effective changes are usually increasing the screw diameter, reducing unsupported length, improving end support, increasing the lead or keeping the screw stationary with a rotating-nut structure. The final design must also be checked for load capacity, rigidity, accuracy, acceleration and thermal expansion.
Need help checking the critical speed of a ball screw?
Send the screw diameter, lead, unsupported length, support arrangement, target linear speed and end-machining drawing to DLY for specification confirmation.
Email: dlyexport2@dlybearing.com

